AI in Education: Challenges, Policies, and Critical Thinking - Redmenta Talks

Introduction

In an insightful discussion, Zan Bishi, CEO and co-founder of Redmenta, and Yan Carell, director of Tallinn European School, shared their experiences and insights regarding the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in education. The conversation revolved around a recent incident that sparked debates about the use of AI tools in academic settings, especially focusing on student ethics, assessment criteria, and the need for guidelines.

The Incident That Sparked a Discussion

In May 2023, a notable incident occurred when a teacher found that an entire class had utilized AI, specifically ChatGPT, to complete a science essay assignment. This sparked considerable unrest among students, leading to a protest against the teacher's decision to assign zeros for those who used AI. Students argued that they were unaware of strict policies regarding AI usage and pointed out that many teachers had encouraged its use. They cited a lack of guidance and clarity on what constituted acceptable or unacceptable use of AI tools.

One particular student articulated a well-structured argument, highlighting issues around plagiarism definitions and copyright ownership. The argument emphasized that AI creates content from scratch and that users of AI tools should be recognized as the legitimate authors. Additionally, a concerned parent noted that AI significantly impacts education and suggested that schools should adapt their policies to incorporate and regulate its use.

In response, the teacher maintained her decision, reinforcing the need for accountability among students. However, she agreed to allow a redo of the assignment in class without the use of technology. This incident ultimately catalyzed the school administration to develop an AI policy.

Development of an AI Policy

Recognizing the need for clarity, the school collaborated with Tallinn Technical University, which had already devised a prototype AI policy. A thorough examination of existing policies from various schools in Europe and the United States helped tailor a more appropriate policy for their institution.

The key components of their AI policy included:

• Defining acceptable and unacceptable use of AI,
• Guidelines on citing AI sources,
• A framework to determine whether the use of AI constituted academic fraud or not.

The implementation of this policy has since fostered a more transparent understanding of AI's role in education, enabling both teachers and students to navigate its capabilities effectively.

Assessing Learning in the Age of AI

One of the main topics of concern during the Redmenta conference was how the use of AI affects assessment criteria. Teachers expressed concerns about whether traditional assessments would still reflect the knowledge and skills that students possessed. The challenge lies in distinguishing whether students demonstrate genuine understanding or if they merely regurgitate information created by AI.

It was suggested that teachers reconsider their assessment formats, focusing on critical thinking and process-oriented evaluations rather than purely relying on the content of essays or reports. For instance, assigning projects wherein students analyze AI-generated texts could provide valuable insights into their critical thinking skills and understanding of the material. This approach emphasizes that the skill of navigating information and aiding comprehension has become increasingly critical in today’s learning environments.

Embracing the Change, Not Resisting It

The conversation stressed that the introduction of AI should not be perceived as a lazy approach to education. Instead, it should be seen as an opportunity to streamline teaching methods and improve student learning experiences. Traditional concerns about technology making students lazier were countered with the idea that using AI can allow educators to focus on fostering higher-order thinking skills, creativity, and problem-solving abilities. Just as calculators revolutionized mathematics instruction, AI can enhance various aspects of teaching and learning.

Challenges of AI Implementation in Education

Despite the enthusiasm surrounding AI integration, challenges persist. Educational institutions must grapple with:

• Adapting assessment methods to align with AI capabilities,
• Encouraging teachers to embrace new technologies while providing proper training,
• Establishing clear policies to protect both educators and students.

It was emphasized that communication and guidance are critical for parents, students, and teachers as they navigate this evolving landscape of education.

---

Keywords

AI, Education, Policies, ChatGPT, Assessment, Critical Thinking, Student Ethics, Plagiarism, Academic Fraud, Teacher Training.

FAQ

1. What was the incident that sparked the conversation about AI in education?

   • An entire class used AI tools to complete a science essay, leading to a teacher assigning zeros for the assignment.

2. How did the school respond to the incident?

   • The school developed an AI policy in collaboration with a local university to provide better guidance on acceptable AI usage.

3. What are the main components of the AI policy introduced?

   • Definitions of acceptable and unacceptable AI usage, citation guidelines, and a framework to assess whether the use of AI constitutes academic fraud.

4. How does AI influence the assessment of student knowledge?

   • The use of AI necessitates a reevaluation of traditional assessment methods to focus more on critical thinking and the process of argumentation.

5. What challenges are associated with implementing AI in education?

   • Key challenges include adapting assessment methods, getting teachers comfortable with new technologies, and establishing protective policies for teachers and students.