Best AI Music Generator in 2024 - SUNO vs UDIO
Howto & Style
Introduction
Music generation has become increasingly popular with the rise of AI technology. Two prominent AI music generators in the market today are SUNO and UDIO. In this article, we will compare these platforms in terms of pricing, features, user experience, and the quality of the music they generate.
Pricing Comparison
Both SUNO and UDIO offer free plans that allow users to generate songs without any cost. However, there are some differences in the limitations and options for paid plans.
SUNO: SUNO offers a free plan that provides 50 credits daily, which is equivalent to 10 songs per day. The paid Pro Plan, priced at $ 10 per month, offers 500 songs per month and includes commercial usage rights.
UDIO: UDIO is currently in beta and offers its services entirely for free. Users can generate up to 1,200 songs per month, with each prompt generating two songs. However, as it is still in beta, the absence of paid plans and limitations may change in the future.
In terms of pricing, UDIO's free plan offers more flexibility and higher song generation limits compared to SUNO's free plan. However, SUNO's paid Pro Plan caters to those who require commercial usage rights.
Features and User Experience
Both SUNO and UDIO have similar user interfaces with menu bars and various tabs for different functionalities. SUNO's main features include home, library, and explore sections, while UDIO offers discover, songs, and playlists sections.
One notable difference is that UDIO provides a persistent generation bar at the top, allowing users to easily generate songs from anywhere in the platform. SUNO, on the other hand, requires users to navigate to the create page for song generation.
Both platforms prioritize user privacy, making all generated songs private by default. Users have the option to publish their songs and share them with others.
Music Generation Results
To compare the music generation capabilities of SUNO and UDIO, several prompts were used to generate songs on both platforms. Here is a summary of the results:
Automatic Mode Comparison: SUNO's automatic mode often produced satisfactory results but lacked high-quality vocals. On the other hand, UDIO's automatic mode showcased better lyrics and overall sound quality, matching the input prompts more effectively.
Custom Mode Comparison: SUNO excelled in generating techno and electronic music, providing high-quality instrumentals and incorporating custom lyrics effectively. UDIO, however, struggled with custom prompts, often not capturing the intended style or matching the input lyrics accurately.
Instrumental Feature Comparison: UDIO's instrumentals outperformed SUNO's by offering more dynamic and diverse beats, particularly in old school hip-hop. SUNO's instrumentals were simpler and somewhat repetitive.
Experimental Prompt Comparison: When presented with an experimental prompt like "telephone ringing," both platforms struggled to generate an accurate representation. UDIO's manual mode attempts to modify prompts for better outputs, but the results may not always align with the initial prompt.
In terms of overall music generation quality, UDIO demonstrated superior sound clarity and high-quality music. However, SUNO's music better matched certain prompts and excelled in specific genres like techno and electronic.
Keywords
AI music generator, SUNO, UDIO, pricing, features, user experience, automatic mode, custom mode, instrumental feature, experimental prompt, sound quality
FAQ
Which AI music generator offers a free plan with more song generation limits?
- UDIO currently provides a free plan with a higher limit of 1,200 songs per month compared to SUNO's free plan.
Does SUNO offer commercial usage rights in its paid plan?
- Yes, SUNO's paid Pro Plan priced at $ 10 per month offers commercial usage rights, allowing users to monetize their videos and content.
Which platform provides better instrumentals for old school hip-hop?
- UDIO offers more dynamic and diverse beats for old school hip-hop instrumentals, outperforming SUNO in this aspect.
Can UDIO modify input prompts for better music generation results?
- Yes, UDIO's manual mode attempts to modify prompts for improved outputs. However, the changes may not always align with the original prompt.
Is there a significant difference in sound quality between SUNO and UDIO?
- UDIO generally offers superior sound clarity and high-quality music compared to SUNO. However, SUNO may better match certain prompts and excel in specific genres.