ELECTRIC vs PETROL CAR – which is REALLY cheaper?? Mini vs Mini review | What Car?

Introduction

When it comes to electric versus petrol cars, the debate often centers around which option is more economical in the long run. With the recent launch of two new Mini hatchbacks—one petrol and one electric—What Car? decided to take both cars on a road trip from London to Birmingham and back to delve into the important comparisons and crunch the real-world numbers.

Overview of the Minis

The two new Minis may look similar on the outside, but they are fundamentally different underneath. The petrol version is powered by a 2-liter turbocharged engine, while the electric model utilizes an electric platform designed for efficiency. Throughout the journey, the two cars showcase different strengths as they navigate motorway and city traffic, as well as rural roads.

Trip Details

Starting from Twickenham, London, the team travels to the Mini Factory in Oxford before heading to Birmingham—a total distance of about 250 miles. The electric Mini has a range of approximately 250 miles, but during the road trip, real-world usage reveals challenges in accurately predicting battery life.

The petrol Mini, on the other hand, boasts a sufficient fuel tank to comfortably handle the distance without needing a refill, providing an immediate advantage in terms of range anxiety for petrol customers.

Road Trip Experience

Throughout the trip, both drivers provided feedback on their experiences in different environments:

Motorway Driving

• Petrol Mini: Averaged just over 45 miles per gallon (MPG) but with some comfort issues, such as road noise and choppy ride quality.
• Electric Mini: Managed about 4.1 miles per kilowatt-hour efficiency, although actual range varied and raised concerns about the accuracy of predicted battery life.

City Driving

• Petrol Mini: While compact and easy to maneuver, it struggled with ride comfort and noise levels.
• Electric Mini: Smooth power delivery and fantastic brake pedal feel made it a strong contender for urban driving.

Handling on Country Roads

Both cars were compared for their driving thrills. While the petrol version offers a sportier feel, the electric variant showed better overall balance, steering response, and body control.

Practicality and Features

Although Mini cars are not typically known for their practicality, both models have similar boot sizes, which left little space for luggage. The electric version's lack of under-bonnet storage and the presence of a large subwoofer in the boot further limited cargo space. In terms of rear passenger comfort, both cars presented challenges, particularly for taller individuals.

Cost Comparison

Comparing long-term ownership costs highlights significant differences. While the electric Mini's purchase price is approximately £7,000 more than the petrol version, much of that could be offset with fuel savings. Over three years, based on fuel and electricity costs, the gap shrinks to just £1,500 when accounting for typical driving scenarios and charging habits.

Monthly Finances

For those interested in financing options, the electric Mini costs about £449 per month compared to £389 for the petrol Mini under the same financing terms.

Conclusion

At the end of the road trip experience, both cars offer unique advantages:

• The petrol Mini excels in initial affordability and range.
• The electric Mini, while more expensive upfront, shows potential for lower ongoing costs depending on individual charging setups.

For those who can integrate an electric car into their lifestyle, the electric Mini stands out as the better overall choice in this comparison.

Keyword

Electric Mini, Petrol Mini, Road Trip, Energy Costs, Practicality, Driving Experience, Ownership Costs, Fuel Economy.

FAQ

1. Is the electric Mini more expensive than the petrol Mini?

• Yes, the electric Mini costs approximately £7,000 more initially.

2. What is the average fuel economy for the petrol Mini during the trip?

• The petrol Mini averaged just over 45 MPG.

3. How does the electric Mini perform in city driving?

• The electric Mini offers smooth power delivery and great brake feel, making it ideal for urban environments.

4. What are the long-term ownership costs difference between the two?

• The electric Mini could ultimately cost around £1,500 more over three years, depending on individual charging habits.

5. Can you lease either Mini?

• Yes, both the electric and petrol Mini can be leased; the electric Mini has a higher monthly payment.