My English Teacher Grades the "Perchance" Essay

My English Teacher Grades the "Perchance" Essay

Introduction

I recently had an interesting experience involving my English teacher who graded an essay titled "Mario the Idea versus Mario the Man." The feedback provided by the teacher highlighted various issues within the essay, shedding light on writing mistakes that can be easily avoided. Here's a comprehensive breakdown of how the teacher reviewed and critiqued this piece of writing.

Detailed Feedback

1. Opening Sentence:

   • Initial Impression: The essay begins on a casual note with the phrase "cool as F," which the teacher marked as a mistake. This choice of language is inappropriate for an academic assignment, especially one for a philosophy class.

2. Contextual Confusions:

   • Dr Pepper Reference: The teacher pointed out an oddity where Mario's thoughts on Dr Pepper's existence are questioned. Furthermore, the essay included a quote from another soft drink, which only added to the confusion.

3. Language and Syntax:

   • **Use of "Perchance":** The term "perchance" was used more than once, standing alone as a one-word sentence. This non-standard usage of language didn't sit well with the teacher and significantly hindered the essay's coherence.

4. Spelling and Grammar:

   • Errors: Basic spelling mistakes, such as the incorrect spelling of "turtle," were flagged. These errors hamper the reading experience and diminish the writer's credibility.

5. Content and Logic:

   • Mario’s Actions: Questions were raised regarding Mario's activities, like crushing turtles, which didn't align with a heroic image. Without proper context, these actions seemed nonsensical.
   • Philosophical Depth: The essay attempted to delve into Mario's existential thoughts, but the lack of context and coherence made the argument weak. The consistent use of "perchance" only added to the confusion without contributing to the essay's philosophical depth.

6. Final Verdict:

   • Teacher’s Recommendation: Instead of assigning a grade, the teacher recommended revising the essay. The various mistakes, including glaring spelling errors and logical inconsistencies, needed to be addressed before proper grading could be considered.

Keywords

Keywords:

• Mario
• Essay
• Philosophy 101
• Dr Pepper
• Perchance
• Spelling Mistakes
• Turtles
• Context

FAQs

FAQ:

1. Why was "cool as F" considered a mistake in the essay?

   • The phrase "cool as F" is informal and inappropriate for an academic setting, particularly in a philosophy class.

2. What was the issue with the Dr Pepper reference?

   • The essay confused the reader by questioning the existence of Dr Pepper and citing another soft drink, which seemed irrelevant and nonsensical.

3. How was the term "perchance" misused in the essay?

   • "Perchance" was used as a standalone sentence multiple times, which didn't fit the academic tone or contribute meaningfully to the essay.

4. What basic spelling mistakes were identified?

   • The word "turtle" was spelled incorrectly, among other errors. These mistakes detract from the essay’s overall quality.

5. What was the confusion surrounding Mario’s actions in the essay?

   • The essay depicted Mario crushing turtles, which contradicted the notion of him being a hero. This lack of context made it difficult to understand the rationale behind his actions.

6. What was the teacher’s final recommendation?

   • The teacher suggested revising the essay due to numerous errors and inconsistencies before a grade could be assigned.